A lot of the feedback in Adobe's public threads for Lightroom's Assisted Culling comes back to the same thing: near-duplicates. People shoot two, ten or twenty frames of one moment and want the software to keep the best of them, while a score applied to each photo on its own can keep all of them or none. Another request in the same threads was to stack bursts and sequences, not every photo of the same topic.
The threads are public if you want to read them in full: https://community.adobe.com/questions-680/assisted-culling-feedback-thread-lrd-1627465/index3.html
A few questions for how you work:
- When you cull, do you judge a frame against a fixed standard (sharp enough, eyes open) or against the frames shot right before and after it?
- How many frames of one moment do you usually take, and how many do you keep?
- For a set of exposure brackets or a sports sequence, what should a culling tool never split up?
For context, imagic compares the frames covering the same moment and sets the rest aside with a reason rather than deleting them, but that is only one way to do it, and we would like to hear how you decide.